[hibeejim21]

So let's get this right:

- He is for sale.

- All players are for sale.

- They won't state a price.

How can a club be in anyway criticised for making a bid if this is the case?  Since value is subjective, in this situation any bid is a fair bid.

---

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

Who has valued him at 500k?

Who said the club hadn't stated a price ? I'd imagine in negotiations Rangers will know full and well how much he is available for. If they aren't willing to meet the price should either move on or test their resolve on the last day. 

[Trusevich]

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

He was the Scottish U19 captain, and has played 25 times for Dundee Utd's first team at the age of 20. If Dundee Utd didn't think he was worth the money, they could easily have simply not signed him. They got stung for the £204k because they thought we'd let him go for f*ck all.

St Johnstone are doing exactly the same thing - not letting their player go for peanuts. A natural solution will be found either way, and neither club will be unhappy at the outcome. That's the way negotiation works. Dundee Utd could take note.

[TheWorthinGer]

So let's get this right:

- He is for sale.

- All players are for sale.

- They won't state a price.

How can a club be in anyway criticised for making a bid if this is the case?  Since value is subjective, in this situation any bid is a fair bid.

---

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

Who has valued him at 500k?

Who said the club hadn't stated a price ? I'd imagine in negotiations Rangers will know full and well how much he is available for. If they aren't willing to meet the price should either move on or test their resolve on the last day. 

Who was asking you?

I'd say they'll take as much as they can get and that means not stating a price - you might ask for less than the buyer would otherwise have paid.

---

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

He was the Scottish U19 captain, and has played 25 times for Dundee Utd's first team at the age of 20. If Dundee Utd didn't think he was worth the money, they could easily have simply not signed him. They got stung for the £204k because they thought we'd let him go for f*ck all.

St Johnstone are doing exactly the same thing - not letting their player go for peanuts. A natural solution will be found either way, and neither club will be unhappy at the outcome. That's the way negotiation works. Dundee Utd could take note.

Whatever amount he goes for - if he goes - will be the price.  Not what these chumps on here want to guess about.  If it was any team but us nobody would interested in the potential transfer fee.

His value, or lack of it, will be seen in the future.

[hibeejim21]

Who was asking you?



Your permission to respond to anything on here is not required.

[TheWorthinGer]

Who was asking you?



Your permission to respond to anything on here is not required.

I never said it was.  Just pointing out that the question was directed at the person bandying figures about.

Thick as Fred is, he's no thicker than you and can answer for himself.

[hibeejim21]

You didn't point any such thing out. Your comment is right underneath mine.

Calling folk "thick" on the internet - when you can't even grasp the basics of football transfers. 

[TheWorthinGer]

You didn't point any such thing out. Your comment is right underneath mine.

Calling folk "thick" on the internet - when you can't even grasp the basics of football transfers. 

"Who was asking you" makes the very point that I wasn't asking you.

How much clearer can it be?

The basics of a football transfer: two clubs agree a price and a player is sold, as long as he agrees to go.

Not two buffoons from Edinburgh are contacted for their less than valuable input on what the price should be then the sale goes ahead at the figure they plucked from their dubiously coloured sky.

And you are thick.  As good saying it here as anywhere else.

Hint: if someone ever approaches you and asks to buy anything that you "own", don't tell them how much you want. Ask how much they will pay.

---

---

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

Who has valued him at 500k?

Does this make it any clearer for the challenged mind?

[hibeejim21]

"Who was asking you" makes the very point that I wasn't asking you.


No. It's the sound of a prick throwing his weight around on an internet forum and then backtracking afterwards.

[TheWorthinGer]

If The Rangers can get £200k for a player who played once for them then £500k shoudln't be a problem for O'halloran.

Who has valued him at 500k?

"Who was asking you" makes the very point that I wasn't asking you.


No. It's the sound of a prick throwing his weight around on an internet forum and then backtracking afterwards.

Are you really so stupid that you don't realise a question under a quote is directed at the quoted individual?


You certainly now look that stupid.

[Fredstersafool]

Why ye waating yer time jim?? The mans a Tadger