[jjamez]

The english fa want a yes man who wont upset the players or argue against them. They want old fashioned school tie who wont do anything radical.

Scotland have a dinosaur in charge who was a half decent manager at times 15 years ago, but even then it was mainly when he was at celtic. Now he's playing catch up.

Both have players of undisputed talent and potential, but england need someone who is radical and will make the changes that are needed ect. The fa is still in the same state it was when clough was rumoured for the position and its still the same mentality now as it was back then. In large parts its really old heads that are from the righr background for them. The only younger person is the man charged with appointing the new manager and his previous job was at west brom and he didnt do great appointing managers there and then theres the fa dna they bleat on about which in itself is against all our strengths.

The fa dna is right idea, wrong execution for what they have at their disposal.

Scotland, they need a younger manager who has half an idea on how to use players like snodgrass, burke, ritchie, mccormack. They essentially could play the same system klopp used and town use and with what they have at their disposal it would probably work

the answer isnt a 60 year old to either scenario (sorry arsene)