[0762]

think carmichael has gone on loan to qots.

http://www.hibernianfc.co.uk/news/6753

Even worse - he's left the club by mutual consent! Just too much competition for places from better Hibs players than him. I wish him well and hope he finds a club that suits his own level and physique.

TBO 0762 I could never get my head round why Alan Stubbs signed him in the first place he looked like a 12 year old playing in a mans team to lightweight to make it with HFC. Only my opinion tho

Yep! Your view of Carmichael is very similar to my own opinion when he first played at ER v Dumbarton(?). I suggested a similar critical observation to my son that the player looked so lightweight and just arrived from schools footie. I never rated his chances of 'making it' based on that initial observation.