[HerefordBull]

Have to agree Worthing........any manager who wins the Scottish Cup again with Hibs will go down in History but that does not make them the most successful Hibs manager. ( afterall most of his wins are in the second tier of Scottish football)  Hugh Shaw in the 40's 50's won 3 league titles and had the European adventure and was there with the famous five so still arguably would be our most successful manager. McMichael took the team to a league title and the Scottish Cup in 1902 so is up for a shout. ( although I realise this falls outside Watties 115 years)

When you look at win percentages these 2 are up there but behind Stein ( who won nothing) and interestingly Stubbs ( however if results carry on as they are this percentage will drop fast!) . However I'd still look at the 40's and 50's as our most successful time as although the Scottish Cup has become Hibs holy grail, it is not the only parameter.