[Salopbaggie]

No Baggy I am just saying that it is a fruitless debate because we will never know what would have happened if he had.

I am not saying he should have or he shouldn't, just he didn't so we will never know what would have happened if he had.  Which is what renders it a fruitless debate.

You are certainly correct that this has been one of the best dynasty's (10 years behind you) and I have a lot of both respect and gratitude for what JP has done for the club.  The only other I could think of was as the time of Giles/Atkinson, though those times were looked on through rose coloured glasses