[bluepooch]

We've had this debate before Dev and I still think Caldwell had the right credentials at the time .As for Jack ,he was a complete unknown and it could have gone one way or another ,every manager has to start somewhere and although it was a baptism of fire Jack felt he was up to it .He had the support of an experienced guy in Tommy Wright but yet again the recruitment in the January transfer window left a lot to be desired ,notable exception Ramsdale .
Recruitment is key to any teams success and it looks like MA is going for previous winners regardless of age ,which suggests proven mentally as well as physically strong players,something we have badly lacked in the last few seasons .
Jimmy Ryan was small but tenacious in the tackle and Morsy was like a bull and when they left we never replaced them ,maybe Wedgebury and Weston can provide that strength again.