Aye! If we had the choice we would opt for the 'goal machine', the scorer of 'goals for fun' v Hearts as well and of course a passionate hibee! The choice of Broony would be different in the fact he was our potential captain and leader for years to come but we sold him on, his choice of course. He could still possibly provide that leadership and organisation at ER but IMO it would be a short-term arrangement unless he is attracted to a coaching career.