[madsteve]

if we must talk about the game i mean thats what i wanted to do before being wummed    i thought he dived if you watch it from the camera angle behind him !! he lets both feet go in the air at the same time !! and yet the village player come in on his left leg first    he neads more practise ive always said that strikers and midfielders should practise this more !! owen used to  

.....but as Keith Hackett says, the challenge met all the criteria to be given as a penalty. Whether Maguire exagerated it or not, it is still a penalty.