18-11-2014, 14:06
Agree with nearly all the comments from everyone who has posted here.
Clarke, Kindon and Stewart shouldn't be classed as legends for me.
I agree that Law and Worthington might have started with us but didn't get enough playing time while at Town to be considered legends.
However total appearances alone isn't enough to also be considered a legend, otherwise players like Nathan Clarke and Jon Dyson would be in with a shout !!!
It has to come down to what was done whilst playing with Town, whether it was winning things, promotion, avoiding relegation, goals or just great play consistently.
So for me, I would include Rhodes and Booth as legends. Rhodes deserves to be there so much more than Marcus Stewart for example. 87 goals in 3 years beats 67 in 4 years.....however I know nearly all those were scored at a lower level.
Not everyone from the title winning teams of the 20's would be in it. Let's face it, an average player can win lots of trophies if he's in a good team...look at Nicky Butt and Phil Neville for Man Utd.
Overall there's 5 players in there I wouldn't have picked.....Kindon, Stewart, Clarke, Law, Worhington.
Clarke, Kindon and Stewart shouldn't be classed as legends for me.
I agree that Law and Worthington might have started with us but didn't get enough playing time while at Town to be considered legends.
However total appearances alone isn't enough to also be considered a legend, otherwise players like Nathan Clarke and Jon Dyson would be in with a shout !!!
It has to come down to what was done whilst playing with Town, whether it was winning things, promotion, avoiding relegation, goals or just great play consistently.
So for me, I would include Rhodes and Booth as legends. Rhodes deserves to be there so much more than Marcus Stewart for example. 87 goals in 3 years beats 67 in 4 years.....however I know nearly all those were scored at a lower level.
Not everyone from the title winning teams of the 20's would be in it. Let's face it, an average player can win lots of trophies if he's in a good team...look at Nicky Butt and Phil Neville for Man Utd.
Overall there's 5 players in there I wouldn't have picked.....Kindon, Stewart, Clarke, Law, Worhington.
In beer there is freedom, in wine there is health, in cognac there is power and in water there is bacteria