[silverbaggie]

Since the requirements have changed and history books are out and we must as individuals have seen them play:-

Derek Kevan (aka The Tank)

He was probably coming to the end of his career with Albion by the time I started watching the Baggies.
I remember that Derek had a fearsome shot on him but, if he ran one on one against the opposition goalkeeper, the ball was more likely to finish up in the Birmingham Road than the net.
One of his goals I remember was in a game against Chelsea when their goalkeeper was Peter Bonetti.
Our left wing had the ball (Chippy?) and moved just inside Chelsea's half. Derek was more central perhaps 10 yards inside the half and the only Albion man upfield.
He called for the ball and the winger didn't so much pass it to him as blasted it straight at him; the ball never touching the turf and being at no more than shin height.
Derek just hit it on the volley and the ball streaked into the net from 40 yards out. So fast did this happen that I could swear that Bonetti was still looking at the winger when the ball went past him.

Another:-  Graham Lovett who had major injuries following car crashes but came back to be selected (controversy) for the 1968 FA Cup Final

And finally two more that I DID see play:-
John Kaye and Joe Kennedy.