Posts: 266
Threads: 41
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
2
Favourite player?
Rondon.
Has the quality but what chance has the bloke got getting supply from Gardner and McClean.
2nd Favourite player?
Evans.
Cant believe Utd let him go as he`s been absolutely superb for us in every game he`s played.
Least Favourite player?
McClean.
Might work aard but the thick irish idiot has zero other qualitys.
Most Overrated?
Fletcher.
Might be a good talker but I`d expect an ex Man Utd midfielder to be able to make simple 5 yard passes.
Most Underrated?
Gamboa.
Could really thrive under someone like Martinez as the modern day full back is all about attacking and I`d say 70%
of all Premier League full backs couldn't defend for toffee.
Posts: 245
Threads: 0
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
2
Favourite player....
At the moment it's got to be Evans. Guy oozes is class and can play anywhere and still put a shift in.
2nd Fave... Mcmanaman. Wish he would play more. Tore Chelsea's defence apart earlier in the season and hasn't had a look in since. If I was him I'd be furious he couldn't get over some of the numpties that start week in week out.
Least fave... Olsson. Been a good servent but the guy frustrates me so much. Gets the ball and hoof. Gets the ball and hoof. Doesn't know how to pass along the ground, even his long balls are shocking. Can't stand him.
Most overrated.. Agree with Fletcher. Doesn't do much for me apart from work hard, thought he was better than that but I suppose he's getting on and anyone can look good in uniteds team with fergie in charge.
Most underrated... Sessegnon. Love this guy to bits and always have. So talented and only recently has started playing. Once again I'd be peed if I was him that he couldn't even get on our bench for the first 10 or so games. Ridiculous from Pulis.
Posts: 1,397
Threads: 16
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
5
But Dan, Pulis IS ridiculous !
Posts: 1,433
Threads: 151
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
7
Favourite player?
Morrison.
Mr Consistent - Long serving and always minimum 7/10. When he does have a bad game you notice all the more. When he plays well, so do we.
2nd Favourite player?
Foster.
While Boaz has been fantastic this season, a confident Foster is one of the best keepers in the country, and loves the Albion.
Least Favourite player?
McClean and Yacob.
Nothing to do with abilities, but I close my eyes every time someone goes past them. A red card waiting to happen both of them.
Most Overrated?
Berahino
£25M you're having a laugh, if we were offered half of that I'd drive him there myself. Pacey and habit of right place - right time. Won't make his own goals and is scared to head a bag of wind
Most Underrated?
Dawson.
Consistent and rarely lets us down, but constantly made the scapegoat and some always looking to replace
Posts: 272
Threads: 5
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
3
Favourite Player.
Mcauley - absolute monster even tho he's "old" now. Seems a nice chap as. Wish he would of come to the club a Bit earlier on in his career but he's been fantastic last few years.
2nd fav. Toss up between Evans an Rondon but probably Rondon as he runs and never moans even tho most the time he gets little service. Came over to us after West ham even tho he had missed one or 2 good chances and clapped us when it was easier just to run inside.
Least fav. Probably Olson (altho this is really hard to pick as I don't dislike any albion player) just because of the amount of poor. Long balls he seems to ping. Even when they reach Rondon he has no support.
Most overrated. I'll go different to those before me and go brunt. I think other teams / pundits rate him highly, where his wand of a left foot has seemingly diminished over the last few years. Puts a decent shift in still tho.
Most underrated. Probably position for position I'll go Mcauley
Posts: 266
Threads: 41
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
2
Fletcher has really pulled his finger out lately and now looks like a player who use to play for Man Utd.
The most overrated player now in this Albion team is James McClean as I just cant see what he brings to the table apart
from hard work, if we had someone like Enrique and Townsend playing down the left we`d be unstoppable.
Posts: 1,093
Threads: 1
Joined: Sep 2014
Reputation:
6
03-01-2016, 22:11
(This post was last modified: 03-01-2016, 22:14 by Slick_Footwork.)
Fav - McAuley
Best defender I've seen at the club in my lifetime. Dominates everyone in the air, decent on the deck and just a good pro.
2nd Fav - Berahino
Although his attitude stinks, I think Saido is a genuine class act and quite responsible for keeping us up last year with several winning goals. Makes great runs off the shoulder and is hands down the best two footed striker of the ball in the Premier League. Wasted when played 'in the hole' so probably best for all parties that he's sold - but if he goes to somewhere like Utd or Arsenal, will easily score 20 goals a season IMO.
Least Fav - McClean
For me, players like McClean are everything wrong with British football. A winger should have more than just 'endeavour' - such as being able to play one twos, link up, thread balls through - none of which McClean can do. The guy always runs the most miles for us, but IMO, he's a lower league player.
Overrated - McClean
IMO is lucky to be a pro. If he didn't have natural fitness, would be playing on a Sunday morning.
Underrated - McAuley
If he was 5 years younger, everyone would be in for him. Going to be tough replacing him though and at his age, that's coming very soon.
