![]() |
Should SG Keep His Job - Printable Version +- Sports Babble - sports forum (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk) +-- Forum: Football (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: English Football Leagues (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=2) +---- Forum: Sky Bet Championship (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=49) +----- Forum: Sheffield Wednesday (https://www.sportsbabble.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=59) +----- Thread: Should SG Keep His Job (/showthread.php?tid=783) |
RE: Should SG Keep His Job - madsteve - 16-11-2014 (16-11-2014, 14:24)Devongone Wrote: A ridiculously high percentage of football managers who are sacked NEVER get the chance to try again elsewhere, yet football fans tend to discuss their potential demise with all the empathy you'd display when fetching the Raid to a bluebottle. Whilst you make a number of good points generally, you haven't addressed the one specific problem relating to Wednesday. That is that SG isn't good enough to be a manager & shouldn't have been appointed in the first place. His previous track record was poor and although he had an initial impact, results always nosedived after a couple of months. Changing managers is a costly process. Not the cost of payoffs but the cost of getting rid of all the previous manager's players & bringing in a new set of players. Teams that have the fewest managerial changes progress the most. The key for us is finding the right man & sticking with him. (16-11-2014, 15:20)Thurnscoe_OWL Wrote: We're not doomed. We're stuck in a rut but are mid table, comfortably. A month ago we were ten points above the relegation zone We are five points above relegation now. Another month and I suspect we will be in the bottom six. RE: Should SG Keep His Job - Maddix - 16-11-2014 I refer you to my signature ![]() RE: Should SG Keep His Job - Thurnscoe_OWL - 17-11-2014 (16-11-2014, 23:00)Maddix Wrote: I refer you to my signature Hard to argue with a persons signature ![]() RE: Should SG Keep His Job - peiowl - 17-11-2014 MM will hang on to him until the New Year when we'll be in the bottom 3. Then he'll get rid. Meanwhile, the season will be shot - yet again. Disagree with devon gone. Another season in pub league wouldn't hurt us? Get real. RE: Should SG Keep His Job - Towinjustonce - 17-11-2014 Get rid, isn't good enough now and never was !! There was always going to be an upturn in results when he got the job as is what happens in most cases. He sets us up not to lose games, never to go out and win them. RE: Should SG Keep His Job - madsteve - 17-11-2014 (17-11-2014, 15:11)Towinjustonce Wrote: Get rid, isn't good enough now and never was !! There was always going to be an upturn in results when he got the job as is what happens in most cases. He sets us up not to lose games, never to go out and win them. Statistically, the upturn is down to a manager departing rather than a new manager taking over. The upturn still happens even if no-one takes over. On average, the upturn last for between 6 & 12 matches so it is worthwhile to sack a manager if you are on the cusp of relegation with 12 matches to go. Overall, changing the manager is costly because the new manager (if he is any good) will want his own coaches & his own players so it means getting rid of the present squad for practically nothing & paying to bring in a squad of similar standard. MM could do a lot worse than read the book, Soccernomics, which gives the blueprint for how to build a club so that it punches well above its weight for several seasons as Dortmund have in Germany & Lyon in France. It takes courage & long term planning but it is the only way that Wednesday will ever make the top half of the PL again. SG cannot do it because he is wedlocked to 442. RE: Should SG Keep His Job - peiowl - 18-11-2014 Only 11 people have voted in the poll????? RE: Should SG Keep His Job - St Charles Owl - 18-11-2014 More will vote once we get a match thread up for our next game and the international break is over. RE: Should SG Keep His Job - A57owl - 18-11-2014 Think the next few games will make or break SG. We need loan signings but nothing has happened as yet RE: Should SG Keep His Job - madsteve - 19-11-2014 All the signings in the world won't save SG. They might give him extra time but bad tactics, infexible formations & poor substitutions will get him the sack eventually. |