[0762]

Following on from that I would think Neilson will be hauled before the beaks for his comments on Saturday. Hes basically accused collum of cheating them which is ironic considering the breaks they have had in recent times from the men in black.

Neilson was harangued by many of his own fans hibeejim and rightly so! He will be hauled before the SFA - just listen to the full content of his undignified radio interview. Many Scottish fans on social media regard him as a bit of a hypocrite esp after his team being given some very fortuitous refereeing decisions previously and the arrogance that he/Hearts really knew that the red card decision was never the correct one  - what about some of the disproportionate pen awards to Hearts Robbie? What a short memory eh but highlighted on bbc radio Sportsound (they are debating the issue at last!) in the past couple of weeks by quite a varied selection of Scottish football fans including Forfar supporters who recently mentioned/criticised  their simulation antics in their league cup tie - apparently looking for free kicks and pens at every opportunity - surprise, surprise - has that shady practise never left Tynecastle after all these years since the Lithuanians were engendering it for all to see? Maybe Saint Johnstone's Brad MacKay was not so far off the mark with recent similar critical comments!!

[struth]

Cmon Jimbo, get real. A great day for Hibs fans, not because yer team hung on for victory against Raith but because HMFC lost at Hamilton- very sad. The thing is, big teams occasionally come a cropper and suffer an unexpected defeat and lo and behold, it happened at Hamilton and shocked the whole of Scottish football . **** all to do with Collum, Hearts deserved to lose on the performance but big teams know how to recover from such a defeat.

yeah, but do Hearts 

[hibeejim21]

To be fair Collum is a xxxx but he should really choose his words a bit more carefully however Collum should not be allowed to ref games he's fecked up to many times ands seems untouchable,

---

Oh jim Celtic won yesterday just for the record,stop being a cock

Now theres a team that know how to complain about referees   

---

Following on from that I would think Neilson will be hauled before the beaks for his comments on Saturday. Hes basically accused collum of cheating them which is ironic considering the breaks they have had in recent times from the men in black.

Neilson was harangued by many of his own fans hibeejim and rightly so! He will be hauled before the SFA - just listen to the full content of his undignified interview. Many Scottish fans on social media regard him as a bit of a hypocrite esp after his team being given some very fortuitous refereeing decisions previously and the arrogance that he/Hearts really knew that the red card decision was never the correct one  - what about some of the disproportionate pen awards to Hearts Robbie - a short memory eh but well highlighted on bbc radio Sportsound (they are debating the issue at last!) in the past couple of weeks by quite a varied selection of Scottish football fans including Forfar supporters who recently mentioned/criticised  their simulation antics in their league cup tie - apparently looking for free kicks and pens at every opportunity!! Maybe Saint Johnstone's Brad MacKay was not so far off the mark with his recent critical comments!!

 Going by tonights highlights collum missed a stonewall pk for accies in the first half as well.

[hfcbounce]

Can't see what the fuss is about Jobbie Neilson said he thought hertz would get a player sent off so they prepared for this happening and trained accordingly so at the end o the day he's fkd up then surely get over it Jobbie ur not UNBEATABLE

GGTTH

[Paigntonhibby]

Tae be honest because hearts arnae in the same division as us they're results are immaterial tae me but imo that was never a foul never mind a sending off. I cannae see what yogi's moaning about either because the ice player could've broken the guys legs

---

That should be ict no' ice

[hibeejim21]

Can't see what the fuss is about Jobbie Neilson said he thought hertz would get a player sent off so they prepared for this happening and trained accordingly so at the end o the day he's fkd up then surely get over it Jobbie ur not UNBEATABLE

GGTTH

There's no fuss,just bemusement at how they mocked and derided hibs fans for feeling craig thomson was biased, yet their own manager is basically calling gollum out as a cheat. Even if the card is rescinded he should have the book thrown at him.

[0762]

I'd say football fans from a good number of Scottish football clubs have taken issue with Willie Collum re some absolutely crappy decisions given against their teams down the years. Indeed various Scottish tabloids chased him down last January, when his refereeing form was dire, and that continued for about 6 weeks. Neilson appeared to try and make it a personal thing against his football club! IMO the Craig Thomson issue is similar but slightly different. He recently awarded a pen to his favourite football club, Hearts, v Dundee. Tell me the last time in the past 10 years that Thomson has awarded a pen to Hibs and we've claimed a few when he has officiated our games and some of those pen claims were stonewallers!!!! Merely a coincidence? And is it a mere coincidence that he has never officiated an Edinburgh derby match since that infamous Scottish Cup final and the thousands of complaints that subsequently landed on the SFA's desk, or deluged it's e-mail system, the following week?